Leg before wicket looks complicated because it is usually explained as a single rule. It is not. It is five separate questions, asked in a fixed order, and the moment the answer to any one of them is no, the batter is not out and the umpire stops asking.
Once you know the order, almost every decision you see on television becomes readable, including the ones that look wrong at first.
The five questions, in order

- Was the delivery legal? A no-ball cannot produce an LBW. The umpire checks this first and nothing else matters if the front foot was over the line.
- Did the ball pitch in line or outside off stump? A ball pitching outside leg stump can never be LBW, however plumb it looks. This is the condition that frustrates most new watchers.
- Did it hit the batter in line with the stumps? Impact must be between the lines of off and leg stump, with one exception covered below.
- Was the batter attempting a shot? If no genuine attempt was made to play the ball, impact outside off stump still counts.
- Would it have gone on to hit the stumps? The ball must be shown to be hitting the wicket, not shaving past it.
All five have to be satisfied. Four out of five is not out.
Why pitching outside leg is an automatic reprieve
A ball that lands outside the line of leg stump cannot get a batter out LBW no matter what happens afterwards. The reasoning is positional. A bowler pitching outside leg has angled the ball across the batter in a way that makes a normal stroke awkward, and the batter standing in front of the stumps is a consequence of that angle rather than a mistake.
This is why a left arm spinner going around the wicket to a right hander, or a leg spinner dropping one down the leg side, will often produce a huge appeal and a flat refusal. The replay shows three reds and the batter still walks away, because the pitching line was never in question.
The shot clause, which is the one most people miss
Condition four is the exception to condition three. If the ball strikes the batter outside the line of off stump, they are normally safe. That protection disappears if the umpire judges that no genuine attempt was made to play at the ball.
Padding away a turning delivery outside off looks safe and usually is, but a batter who thrusts the front pad at the ball with the bat tucked behind the leg can be given out. The umpire is being asked whether the bat was making a real attempt to meet the ball, not whether it happened to be nearby.
Umpire’s call, and why the same ball can be out and not out
Under the Decision Review System the on field decision stands when ball tracking shows a marginal result. Three things are measured: where the ball pitched, where it struck the pad, and whether it was hitting the stumps. For the first two, more than half the ball must be in line. For the third, the centre of the ball must be hitting a zone inside the outer edges of the stumps and below the top of the bails.
If any of those three falls in the margin, the review returns umpire’s call and the original decision is kept. The same delivery can therefore be out when given out and not out when given not out. That is not a flaw being tolerated, it is the deliberate design: tracking is a prediction, and the system refuses to overturn a human decision on a prediction that close.
What does not matter, whatever the crowd thinks
| Common claim | Actual position |
|---|---|
| The ball hit the pad first so it must be out | Only if all five conditions are met |
| It hit him on the back leg so it is too high | Height is judged by the tracking, not by which leg |
| He was well outside the crease so he cannot be out | Distance down the pitch affects the prediction, not the right to appeal |
| It struck the pad outside off, so not out | Not if the batter made no attempt to play |
| The ball was spinning so it would have missed | Tracking accounts for spin already imparted, not for what might have happened |
One last detail that decides more appeals than any other. If the ball touches the bat or the glove holding the bat before it hits the pad, the appeal dies instantly. Bat first and LBW is finished, whatever the rest of the replay shows.
